Tuesday, January 28, 2025

My trailblazer toll

"Are you the first in your family to go to college?"

I fielded this question from an associate at a law firm I was interviewing with after I explained how I wanted to make my family proud by becoming a lawyer and also so I could help provide a financially stable future for them. I previously researched the background of the attorney I was meeting with, familiarized myself with all of the prior work the firm completed, and wrote down answers to potential questions I was expecting to be asked during the interview. However, I was not prepared to answer to such a personal question.

I answered no; both my mother and father hold bachelor's degrees. I assumed (maybe naively) that even though I was a second-generation student, I could not relate to any experience that a first-generation student may have. 

It was not until I began reading Alejandra Campoverdi's First Gen: A Memoir that I became aware of what a "First and Only" was. She defines Firsts and Only as those who are the first generation or only person in a family, community, or social demographic group to cross a threshold. Although I was familiar with the term first-generation to refer to students who were the first in their family to graduate college, I was unaware of the broader definition of the term until I arrived in law school.

According to Campoverdi, there are common dynamics associated with being a First and Only: experiencing imposter syndrome, becoming a parentified child, or navigating multiple cultures. However, when I read Campoverdi's description of what is commonly known as "breakaway guilt," I could not ignore my experiences any longer.

Breakaway guilt is known as the collection of negative feelings associated with the decision to pursue higher education while feeling remorseful for "leaving the family behind." Common feelings include deep regret about prioritizing academics over familial duties or shame about pursuing upward mobility.

One common experience associated with breakaway guilt is a student receiving conflicting messages from their family: one to remain at home, but the other to achieve status in the outside world. I experienced this tension when leaving my hometown to attend college in a different state. 

My family was excited for me to broaden my horizons, gain new perspectives, and go create a successful name for myself. Although both of my parents attended college, I would be the first in my family to attend what is considered an elite academic institution. 

But on the other hand, I provided a lot of emotional support for my family members at home. Because I am the oldest daughter in my family, I was expected to be a role model for my younger brother, be a listening ear for my mother, and help mediate any family conflicts or tensions. By leaving home to attend college, those familial duties that typically fell to me went unassigned. 

Like many other students experiencing breakaway guilt, I constantly felt conflicted. I knew that the best way to honor my family's sacrifices to help get me into college was to always give 100% effort and remain focused on doing my absolute best. But on the flip side, I felt guilty I was not at home to provide tangible and emotional support to my loved ones. Although they reassured me they would function just as smoothly without me present, I could never stop the little voice in my head saying I was selfish for prioritizing myself.

Although we may assign mostly negative sentiments to breakaway guilt, Campoverdi encourages us to not "wish those feelings away" because they can be a source of strength. Those feelings remind us of our roots, our familial ties, and where we came from. 

As I move through my law school experiences, I will hold onto the advice from Campoverdi. I never want to forget or wash over all of the moments that made me who I am. I am proud of my background. I am proud of being a First and Only. And I am proud of the perspective I bring to all of the spaces I enter into. 

And at the end of the day, I hope you can tap into that pride as well. 


Labels: , , ,

6 Comments:

At January 30, 2025 at 2:33 PM , Blogger S said...

I really connected with what you wrote. Although I’m not the eldest daughter like you are, I am an only child and similarly shoulder a significant amount of the emotional support labor for my family back home. Just like you, I feel a conflicting sense of guilt for leaving home and the family while wanting to focus on the task at hand (law school) to make them proud. I appreciate you linking these feelings to Campoverdi’s text, which helps provide some perspective and advice. Thank you for posting this!

 
At February 4, 2025 at 2:26 PM , Blogger M said...

Thank you for sharing your experience with breakaway guilt. I often think about the toll that this takes on me, and I strongly relate to the conflicting feelings between staying home and messaging I get from my family. I am an older sister, but lived for 17 years as the youngest in my family. At 17 I had to learn how to be an older sister, and I felt a lot of obligation to stay close to home to help raise my sister and to have a strong relationship with her. I chose my college based on this need to stay close to raise her, but it was not the right choice for me. For law school, I took the step to prioritize my own education and wellbeing by moving away for the first time. Breakaway guilt and being a parentified child is so common in First and Onlys, and the emotional toll that it takes, and balancing that toll in addition to law school is no small task. I like to remind myself that by going away to school, I am setting an example for my younger sister so that one day maybe she can follow in my footsteps instead of being a first and only herself.

 
At February 5, 2025 at 10:29 AM , Blogger RK said...

Your discussion of breakaway guilt really resonated with me. Like you, I think I often notice the conflicting messages my family sends to me. While it's consciously or not, I don't think our families can understand that we do feel guilt not being there for them. However, I never thought of this guilt as a strength. Your point on how this guilt can be viewed as a reminder of our roots really changed my perspective. This "guilt" reminds us of our background, our families, and our reason for striving so hard. We should all be proud of every experience that has brought us where we are today!

 
At February 5, 2025 at 10:54 AM , Blogger C.A.L. said...

Dear AKJ,

Thank you for sharing your experiences and insights. I want to acknowledge that your description of being a second-generation student closely mirrors that of those of us who are first-generation, so please consider yourself a full member of the community. To me, the label “first-generation” is more about actual lived experiences than a definitional description. That said, while reflecting on your discussion, I started to wonder how I, as a first-generation individual, can prevent the next generation from experiencing the similar trauma that you, others, and I have faced as parentified children.

My family and I are also very close, so I completely understand the guilt associated with leaving your family behind as you move on to the next chapter of your life. I stayed local for college and worked full-time to help support my mother and younger brother. My mother always encouraged me to attend college and never discouraged me from moving away. However, because of the strength of our relationship, I convinced myself that I needed to stay local. Part of my sacrifice in going away to law school was ensuring they were emotionally and economically prepared for my absence. For the future, I worry that having a strong relationship with my future children will lead to similar feelings for them. I don’t want my trauma to be what holds back the next generation from seeking new challenges. I want my children to have the same pride you described above.

 
At February 7, 2025 at 7:07 PM , Blogger James said...

Thank you for sharing your experience with the emotional challenges of upward mobility. Your discussion of "breakaway guilt" is especially relatable, as it captures the conflict between pursuing personal success and feeling responsible for family.

What makes this piece stand out is your shift in perspective—seeing your background not as an anchor to our past but as a source of strength moving forward.

 
At February 7, 2025 at 11:40 PM , Blogger NAM said...

Hi AKJ,

I really resonated with your experience, especially the idea of breakaway guilt. I also referenced this topic in my blog post. When I first left home for law school, it felt like stepping into a new world where my family had little insight into. Even though my family is also super supportive, there was a huge disconnect when I talked about school. There was a constant push and pull between focusing on school and staying true to the family oriented person I was. I really like the way you framed it as those feelings being a reminder of where we come from. I now see that feeling as a part of what keeps me grounded as I move into new spaces on my law school journey.

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home