First-gen financial literacy
When I get my first job after I pass the bar, I’m going to make more money than my parents ever have. It’s an incredible accomplishment and a testament to their sacrifice that I am able to make this financial leap. Yet, since my first paycheck when I was fifteen, I’ve never learned how to set money aside "responsibly."
My first job
My first job was at El Pollo Loco which was a ten-minute walk from my home. I got the job because I did what my parents told me to do: walk in and ask if they were hiring. I had already done this at several other fast-food chains within walking distance and been summarily rejected. I remember joking with my friends that I couldn’t even get hired at McDonalds. At El Pollo Loco, though, I was rewarded for my “persistence and grit.”
My parents encouraged me to get a job but they insisted that I wouldn’t be helping with bills or giving any portion of my paycheck to them. I know I could have helped but they didn’t want me to work for the sake of money. To them, a job meant learning responsibility and sacrifice. It meant that I wouldn’t be able to hang out with my friends whenever I wanted because I was scheduled for a shift. It meant that a movie and a dinner literally cost “two hours of my time.”
I learned the value of time management and responsibility soon enough, but I didn’t know what to do with the money coming in. My parents were focused on keeping us in school and keeping food on the table. I asked my older sister for advice, and she told me to “just spend it on what you want.” So that’s what I did.
Poor habits
My dad helped me apply for my first Discover credit card when I started college. I could use the card to front the costs for textbooks, class registration, and anything else I might need. He instructed me to pay off the statement balance in full every month, but he didn’t explain why. At that point, I didn’t know what a credit score was, and I was already in the habit of spending money on whatever I wanted.
Eventually, I just tried submitting a minimum payment on my credit card bill and waited to see if anything would happen. The bank accepted the payment and sent me a bill the next month with another minimum payment due. I was so excited that I thought I had hacked the system. I didn’t tell my dad because I would technically be disobeying him, but he never asked about my bills so I never took the initiative and talked to him about it. If the bank didn’t have a problem with it, why would he? I wasn’t living in poverty but after reading excerpts from Hillbilly Elegy, I realize I was always planning what to buy with my next paycheck.
For a lot of students like me, the idea of a credit score was so intangible. I had no idea I needed to “build up” my credit score? Why? I was just an undergraduate student making minimum wage. If I needed to buy a car or a home, I’d worry about that when I was making more money.
I think this is a big struggle for a lot of first-gen students like me; we never experienced the benefits of accrued wealth. We are more likely to graduate with debt and much more likely to drop out of college. It’s difficult to convince myself to set aside money that’ll be a boon to me 40 years later when right now, my student loan debts are going to compound on itself every single month. The ever-present problems that have stood before us our entire lives, such as paying for groceries or rent, have built poor habits that make us want to spend in the present. Furthermore, the costs of social mobility, such as student loans and buying our first car, make it even harder to break these poor habits.
One step at a time
Today, I know what a credit score is and how stupid I was for thinking I had figured out a loophole when I was really accumulating interest and undermining my credit score. I read Dave Ramsey, and I asked financially literate people around me for advice. Every weekend, I go through my bank statements and input charges into QuickBooks to keep track of my spending. I set monthly budgets for myself on food, personal spending, and hobbies.
I told my parents about the stupid minimum payments I had been making and they wanted to help me. They helped me co-sign on a new car they bought so my credit score could slowly get back up. With my monthly budget, now, I'm always paying off my credit card statement in full. When I was working full-time, I started saving money in my Roth IRA and mutual funds account with an eye to the future.
Financial literacy is an ongoing process, especially when you don’t have a safety net to fall back on. Having worked full-time at a few jobs now, I’m still learning. Now that I’m going to have a salary that eclipses my parents, I’m going to have the luxury of setting aside money, but I’m constantly worried that I’m making a mistake. I’ve resolved to take it one step at a time and to not stress over money I don’t have. It's an odd reversal of my prior bad habit of spending money I didn’t have.
3 Comments:
Thank you for sharing, James! I also grew up without learning financial literacy from my parents. My dad always told me that credit cards were bad, and I believed him. I later learned that he said that because he was afraid I would start spending more than I could afford, leaving me buried in personal debt on top of school loans. When I started having a steady income I ended up over-correcting and saving every penny I made, continuing to live as if I didn't make any money. It wasn't until my partner and I started talking about moving in together that I was exposed to a whole different world of setting money aside and being okay with spending when I need to, and that credit cards are not necessarily a bad thing. I often think about the fact that one day I'm going to be poor, and the next day I will wake up and be making big law money. More money in one year than I have made in all my years of working combined. I don't know how I can make so much money while my family continues to live in poverty, but I agree with you that we have to take it one step at a time. One day, maybe it won't be so weird anymore.
Thank you for sharing! Just recently, I had to explain to my dad why it would be best for him to pay off his credit card in full to avoid accruing interest and paying more over time. These are conversations he probably should have had with me, but instead, I find myself having them with him. It really shows how much of this financial learning we have to figure out on our own and sometimes even teach back to our parents.
I really wish our public schools did a better job of teaching basic financial literacy. So many students, especially those from immigrant or low-income families, are expected to make major financial decisions without any guidance. We are encouraged to apply for college, open bank accounts, take out loans, and get jobs, but no one teaches us how to manage a paycheck, avoid debt, or understand how interest works. Instead, we are left to learn through mistakes that often come with long-term consequences. Having trusted mentors or financial education early on could make such a difference. We should not have to wait until adulthood to feel like we are finally learning how to navigate money. Students like us deserve the chance to start off strong, not start off catching up.
Financial literacy is a crazy thing. I know none of my family members ever taught me how to spend or save my money. Neither of my parents explained to me how money works. I think they were both too embarrassed about their own finances to try and teach anything to me. It's hard to learn good habits when your parents don't have good habits. They are both major spenders. My grandpa, on the other hand, is a money hoarder. I consider him very much like Mr. Krabs in that respect. Having to navigate how I handle my own finances has been trying to find a good balance between those. I learned about paying off your credit card every month and having a High Yield Savings Account from Reddit. As an adult, I have worried so much that I will end up in a situation where I run out of money. I am so afraid of that because I know my mom wouldn't be able to help me and I never would want to ask my dad for money. However, I have come to realize how much I enjoy getting myself treats. I am still trying to find a good balance between the two, but hopefully I won't be as concerned when I'm making "big girl money."
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home